Extraordinary claims. Ordinary investigations.

The Billy Meier hoax photographs

meiernavealca1

Seen above, a shot of Billy Meier’s “weddingcake” craft, allegedly an extraterrestrial device. A strange appendage is circled in blue. What could it possibly be?

According to The Billy Meier case: more conclusive “smoking gun” proof of deception, that’s just the handle of a garbage can lid that can be found on Meier’s farm:

meiertampalaca

Read the full analysis for much more details. But maybe the best part is the “explanation” given by Meier (or his aliens) for why the lower part of an alleged alien craft looks exactly like a garbage can lid, complete with a handle. From Meier’s 254th Contact Report, November 28, 1995:

Ptaah: “. . . As far back as the 1920s we worked with flying devices you have named the ‘Wedding Cake Ship,’ … we endeavored to transmit all of the necessary data regarding the vehicles’ shape to terrestrial scientists, in the form of telepathic impulses, to assist them in developing flying disks on Earth … We thoroughly investigated the entire situation and discovered that the old, newly re-emerged drawings were used for the design and production of these receptacle covers. … This, then, is how the shape of the container covers came about, which, as I mentioned earlier, strikingly resemble the lower rim section and undercarriage on our flying devices.”

It’s more ridiculous than his excuses as to why his photos of the pretty Pleiadian girls were exactly like dancers from the Dean Martin show. Photographing an American show on TV and claiming it was a real contact with aliens is also not much different from photographing a book illustration and claiming it was from a time travel trip. Click the image below to check “SpaceTimeNews” comparison:

meierdinosaurhoax2qhgjksa

But I digress. Knowing how Meier created his alien ship, and having a photograph of an enthusiast on his farm proudly holding a garbage can lid (probably assuming it was obviously different, which it is not), tempted me to use some Photoshop skills to correctly scale the Weddingcake craft. The result:

tampalixoplieadiana

Once again, I recommend the reading of The Billy Meier case: more conclusive “smoking gun” proof of deception for more on Meier’s garbage affair. Also, please note the man above is not Meier, and the actual model created over the garbage lid is not golden, but silver. The montage is just to show scale. And get some laughs from all of this.

- - -

Still trying to separate fact from fiction? How about an online education? There are plenty of online college courses to help you figure things out. There are even grants for education to help with the finances.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Fark
  • Furl
  • Reddit
  • Slashdot
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati
Posted in Aliens, People, Skepticism, UFOs |

15 Comments so far

  1. [...] The Billy Meier hoax photographs [...]

  2. David October 9th, 2007 4:21 am

    well, i’ve looked through hundreds of billy meier contact photos and the ONE you show here resembles NOTHING in the other few hundred. I’m not sure where you got this shoddy photo, but if this is your debunker of the billy meier case, you are sadly unprofessional and inexperienced…do some research…sheesh..

    DB

  3. jessi December 6th, 2007 12:07 am

    well I think Billy saw something at one point.. he saw an alien spaceship YES!! but then he got carried away.. and the entire contacts and messanger and chosen crap was created.. I am a 100% ufo believer…

  4. fight evil December 22nd, 2007 8:05 pm

    Meier is known to have been a hoaxer at the end as it got out of control and frankly there was money to be made. But that does not mean that all his material is fake. If they put you on the ’stand’ tomorrow and examine your entire life, will you be found flawless or 100% honest? Of course you will NOT BE, thus are you a good man or woman or a bad man or woman? That is the logic you apply for you own personal convenience. God does not work that way and you are fortunate, as well as you brothers and sisters that see reality as you do.

  5. forgetomori » Jesus! Say "Cheese" December 29th, 2007 1:13 am

    [...] Siragusa is certainly not the only contactee to copy images from common sources and present them as extraordinary photographs of, from or by extraterrestrials. Swiss contactee Billy Meier also sells photos from books and even TV shows as alien images. [...]

  6. Orville C. Story January 22nd, 2008 6:43 pm

    I’ve studied hundreds of ufo vid’s and have seen many which can’t be explained by conventional means, as for Billy’s I’m not impressed. Maybe one could possibly be real, but the bottom line is if just one of them is hoaxed then it discredits all the rest. The wedding cake is especially suspect since it suspiciously appears attached to trees in most photos, in others the photographer would have had to been free flosting in the air to take the image and in one I noticed it was taken in proximation to what clearly is a model car in the foreground. I find his evidence lacking and I think it only helps to discredit the phenomenon which in my opinion is REAL and there are many GOOD videos out there to prove it, none of them being Billy’s.

  7. russ February 12th, 2008 6:52 pm

    YAWN! heard it all before!,

    first of all lets this straight - just because there are a couple of questionable curious aspects does not and simply CANNOT in any way invalidate the strentgth of the remaining overall vast amount of supportive evidence. In fact this is only to be expected - considering the sheer volume of that evidence itself.

    Also the argument often put forward by skeptics - that if they think they have debunked one or two photos - then by extension of this that the rest then must surely be fake - this very simply can NOT carry forward - owing again to the overwhelming impregnability (and irreproducibility!) of that remaining volume of sheer hard pyhsical evidence.

    more specificlly - (and just briefly)

    on wedding cake - if one examines the video billy took (using a very early SABA brand of european camera) the zoom employed shows unquestionably that we are dealing with a very very large object - that simply cannot be a trashcan - the forced perspective theories do not hold up here.

    on dean martin lookalike - if one is to examine carefully a photo of the woman in question - there are hugh facial discrepencies (eg. size of forehead, cheekbones etc.) It requires bit of closer scrutiny - but once the realisation of this sets in - it starts to make sense that yes - an image of this woman may surely have overlaid ON TOP OF whatever photo billy took of the original pleadian girl - and that really this is the only real possibility - again as a result of the very perceivable and unquestionably facial incongruity that is made apparent under closer examination. THerefore the conclusion that must surely be reached for the critical thinker is that indeed there must have had to have been tampering with billy’s original photos as he took them.

    on dino shot - if one looks more closely - its not really an exact match is it! therefore proving nothing.

    go to my youtube site listed above - and view the videos - ‘meier case reopened’ parts 1 and 2.
    also there is a brand new film out - entitled ‘the silent revolution of truth’
    also there is an entire free book online available for download entitled ‘ufo contact with the Pleiades’

    meier was able to accurately describe the exact nature of the chemical composition of jupiter’s ring before science got there.

    also he was able to accurately describe the nature of the atmosphere on venus beneath the dense cloud cover - once again before mainstream science got there.

    billy is for real….
    and humans beings choose to ignore this at their absolute peril.

  8. Mark Scalise February 27th, 2008 4:59 pm

    I first saw Billy’s book when I was 9 or 10 years old, and was sure the pictures were real. As an adult, even one with no forensic knowledge, they look pretty damn fake. I would love to believe in UFOs, ghosts, even a supreme being. Still looking to be convinced, but haven’t been, and photos/videos will never qualify as convincing evidence for me. Some things you just need to experience firsthand to believe.

  9. stevo February 29th, 2008 1:35 am

    seems like the last poster doesn’t have much knowledge in general. If he did he would know that the meier shots in fact hold up to all kinds of scientific scrutiny. his comment is a common one - but is lacking in any grounding really - ie entirely a subjective viewpoint. Personally I am of the opinion that because meier’s shots are so detailed adults rule them out becuase it is so very rare that such close detailed photos are available of ufos… usually more often than not, they are just blobs.. and they just go - no way can that be real - (ie because of their adult programming/conditioning)

  10. Loadabollocks March 11th, 2008 12:44 pm

    Stevo - If the Meier shots hold up to ‘all kinds of scientific scrutiny’ I haven’t seen any evidence of that - can you let me know where to look??? Honestly? these are the worst ufo pictures I have ever seen … I can’t beleive this guys making money out of people like you. Very, very sad! Also, I’ve got a very interesting jelly mould in my kitchen how much do you think I can make??

  11. Aditya Sonakia April 28th, 2008 3:43 pm

    The Photograph where the person is holding the wedding cake ship is not true.

    It may the case, that the person is holding the garbage can lid.
    It is definately faked, just to show the mission as a fake.

  12. Mori April 28th, 2008 11:43 pm

    Aditya, please read the note carefully, as it’s clearly informed that the image of the person holding the wedding cake ship is indeed a montage, “just to show scale”.

    The original one is linked, where the man is holding a garbage can lid from one of Meier’s farms.

  13. jesus April 29th, 2008 1:39 pm

    Oooooh! photoshop in 1970?

    wuaaaoooo.

  14. stevo July 7th, 2008 3:49 pm

    in respect to dino shots….

    there are distinct differences between the two respective dino shots -

    first of all differences in relaton to detail on respective dinos - ie. the position and size of white detail/white-stipes.

    Also there is the issue of the surrounding colouring that is noticeably absent on the left photograph…supposedly billy’s photo

    both of these points serve towards towards negating the prospect of billy having taken a photo of the dino from the book that is shown - and that obviously something else is going on here - question being - what?? ie what kind of falsifying and/or replacement - as this is really the only logical possibility..

    bottom line - there is FAR FAR more evidence IN FAVOUR of the meier case being true than that of being false.

    especially the issue of the ufo - rising up over the distant hill/horizon - which virtually gives proof positive in terms of the following….

    that Billy meier is indeed for REAL.

    - & that everyone should ought to have a read of HENOCH PROPHECIES to know what might be in store for mankind unless we change our ways - and change them fast!!!

  15. eddie July 17th, 2008 7:23 am

    well what company do you work for?, as the same as jonathan reed case they want to disacredit these guys, whts the problem on letting the world know? you are not coming out victorious, one day the truth will be shown

Leave a reply